• MigrationDesk is a community, not an agent (nor is affiliated with any). You can post here without an account, but all unregistered posts will be queued for moderator approvals. You can register a free account to bypass moderation and enjoy additional features such as post notification, Live Chat etc.

Subclass 189 CO asked to submit the employment verification via EA and marriage proof

Jayesh

Wanderer
Messages
14
Points
1
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15
Dear all,

I had submitted visa file on Feb 19 and claim 6 years of experience for total 4 different organisation. Out of six years first two years i got cash salary rest of job i received salary in bank.
Now case officer comments to provide relevant skill employment verification letter from concern authority...as i am mechanical engineer so have to go for EA to verify employment..and it is very tuff...so can u guide me which doc have to put for employment verification for cash and bank salary...and pls let me know why they give me such comment ..bcos even dibp can verify my employment by their end even thought why dibp send me to EA
 
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15

PK-Adelaide

Collaborator
Entitled Member
Messages
425
Points
28
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01
Because EA is the authority which can verify your employment by all means. Like, authenticity, skill level etc. This is the reason i always recommend to do a relevant skilled experience assessment before claiming the experience in skill select, if you are not 100% sure. Because, in worst case if you cannot submit sufficient proof for claimed point, your visa application will get rejected.

May i know in which subclass did you apply?

Employment verification cash payment.
You need to provide all possible documents to claim this. a letter from the employer showing your monthly salary, mode of payment, your roles &responsibilities etc. Since the payment was in cash, you won't get any tax document. But the chances are slender to get this considered by EA.
@mohsinciddiki @Dileep @MysticRiver - what you guys think?
 
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01

mohsinciddiki

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
1,837
Points
83
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20
Well, that is quite strange for the CO to ask for RSEA as it is not a requirement from DHA as well as by EA. But clearly, I believe CO is unable to evaluate your experience based on your claims against the requirements for your occupation and is referring to the relevant assessment body which is quite logical. For documents, as @PK-Adelaide suggested, you need to upload all possible documented proof of your employment as EA sometimes become very crude in verifying the experience and asks the maximum documents possible. So better be prepared well in advance and submit your case with salary slips mentioning mode of payment as cash, your life insurance from company having your name on the insurance card etc. as a secondary proof, any govt related document which shows your relation with your employer (Form 16, income tax return etc. )
 
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20

MysticRiver

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
13,610
Points
113
Now case officer comments to provide relevant skill employment verification letter from concern authority
This is the first time I have heard a CO asks for RSEA. In the past, EA maintained that RSEA is optional though "highly recommended". However, someone reported earlier that when he called the DHA hotline, the operator told her he needs to do RSEA. Maybe that's an indication that DHA is shifting its policy about RSEA.
 

Jayesh

Wanderer
Messages
14
Points
1
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15
S
Because EA is the authority which can verify your employment by all means. Like, authenticity, skill level etc. This is the reason i always recommend to do a relevant skilled experience assessment before claiming the experience in skill select, if you are not 100% sure. Because, in worst case if you cannot submit sufficient proof for claimed point, your visa application will get rejected.

May i know in which subclass did you apply?

Employment verification cash payment.
You need to provide all possible documents to claim this. a letter from the employer showing your monthly salary, mode of payment, your roles &responsibilities etc. Since the payment was in cash, you won't get any tax document. But the chances are slender to get this considered by EA.
@mohsinciddiki @Dileep @MysticRiver - what you guys think?
Subclass : 189
Cash salary for first two years having below listed doc

Pay slip with indication mode of payment CASH
form 16
Form 26AS with no entry bcoz of cash salary
CA certificate for 2 years
Reference letter
Experience certificate
Appointment letter
Is there any other doc is required and such document enough..???
How much percent chances??
Thanks in advance guys u pol doing great8 job
 
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15

mohsinciddiki

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
1,837
Points
83
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20
form 16
Form 26AS with no entry bcoz of cash salary
These are two main documents which should be enough with other listed ones
 
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20

mohsinciddiki

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
1,837
Points
83
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20
Which 2 docs r required pls mention
Quoted above. Form 16 and 26AS as they are third-party documents and will be required by EA
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Jayesh
MSA
2018-08-02
Skill
261111
SC
189/190
Point
75/80
EOI
2018-08-17
Inv.
2018-11-11
App.
2018-12-22
CO
2019-03-27
PCC
2019-02-23
HC
2019-02-18
Grant
2019-06-03
IED
2020-02-20
Messages
848
Points
43
MSA
2017-11-23
Skill
261313
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-11-26
Inv.
2018-12-11
App.
2019-01-31
PCC
2019-01-20
HC
2019-04-15
Dear all,

I had submitted visa file on Feb 19 and claim 6 years of experience for total 4 different organisation. Out of six years first two years i got cash salary rest of job i received salary in bank.
Now case officer comments to provide relevant skill employment verification letter from concern authority...as i am mechanical engineer so have to go for EA to verify employment..and it is very tuff...so can u guide me which doc have to put for employment verification for cash and bank salary...and pls let me know why they give me such comment ..bcos even dibp can verify my employment by their end even thought why dibp send me to EA
Did u do skill assessment from EA
 
MSA
2017-11-23
Skill
261313
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-11-26
Inv.
2018-12-11
App.
2019-01-31
PCC
2019-01-20
HC
2019-04-15

Dileep

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
1,868
Points
113
MSA
2017-04-27
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2017-12-29
Inv.
2018-01-03
App.
2018-01-16
CO
2018-06-26
PCC
2017-12-13
HC
2018-01-21
Grant
2018-09-18
IED
2018-12-10
The docs mentioned above should be fine. I don't think they will require any further. Here are the ones which I had submitted:
1. Duty letter - on company letter head with salary, designation, weekly hours of work, and job responsibilities, with email and phone contact of the signing manager.
2. Salary slips/bank statements.
3. Form 26as
4. Contracts
5. Visa copies for the job which I had in Qatar

All the best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jayesh
MSA
2017-04-27
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2017-12-29
Inv.
2018-01-03
App.
2018-01-16
CO
2018-06-26
PCC
2017-12-13
HC
2018-01-21
Grant
2018-09-18
IED
2018-12-10

PK-Adelaide

Collaborator
Entitled Member
Messages
425
Points
28
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01
S
form 16
Form 26AS with no entry bcoz of cash salary
Wonder whether these docs which are tax related have any mention about salary since it is paid in cash.

If you have a form 16 for this period ( salary as cash), you might have filed the tax return. Then you can also attach ITR-V.

Note: uploading any document( like FORM26AS) without any entry about salary may adversly affect the application.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jayesh
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01

Jayesh

Wanderer
Messages
14
Points
1
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15
Wonder whether these docs which are tax related have any mention about salary since it is paid in cash.

If you have a form 16 for this period ( salary as cash), you might have filed the tax return. Then you can also attach ITR-V.

Note: uploading any document( like FORM26AS) without any entry about salary may adversly affect the application.
@PK-Adelaide thanks a lot as salary is in cash for first 2 years and its non taxable slab so i had not filled ITR but having generated bill 26AS and form 16 so will put that...thanks dear u had released my so much pressure god bless u
 
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15

Jayesh

Wanderer
Messages
14
Points
1
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15
@PK-Adelaide thanks a lot as salary is in cash for first 2 years and its non taxable slab so i had not filled ITR but having generated bill 26AS and form 16 so will put that...thanks dear u had released my so much pressure god bless u
Yah in salary slip it is clearly written that mode of payment cash
 
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15

PK-Adelaide

Collaborator
Entitled Member
Messages
425
Points
28
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01
@PK-Adelaide thanks a lot as salary is in cash for first 2 years and its non taxable slab so i had not filled ITR but having generated bill 26AS and form 16 so will put that...thanks dear u had released my so much pressure god bless u
Sorry to ask again. whether Form26AS has any entry about your salary whic his paid in cash? if not, why you need to upload that?
 
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01

Jayesh

Wanderer
Messages
14
Points
1
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15
Sorry to ask again. whether Form26AS has any entry about your salary whic his paid in cash? if not, why you need to upload that?
26AS has no entry as salary in cash
But it is d evidence that during that period i was work and salary is in cash that's why it shown blank
 
Skill
233512
SC
189
Point
75
EOI
2018-12-08
Inv.
2018-12-10
App.
2019-02-07
CO
2019-05-10
PCC
2019-01-10
HC
2019-01-15

PK-Adelaide

Collaborator
Entitled Member
Messages
425
Points
28
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01
26AS has no entry as salary in cash
But it is d evidence that during that period i was work
A blank Form26AS in no way stands as proof that you were working. but instead, it can be considered as a solid proof that you might not be working during this period.

and salary is in cash that's why it shown blank
hmm... i don't think you have to show something which is blank. A blank Form26AS is not a proof of salary received in cash. it can also interpret as no salary received.


For a period of employment where salary is received in hand (cash), you can support your claim only with the docs/proofs from the company.
they are,
1. Letter from the employer with duties and responsibilities during this period.
2. Salary slip with mode of payment- cash
3. Reference Letter
4. Appointment letter
5. Service letter (with annual salary drawn)
7. Appraisal letters etc.

A blank Form26AS or Form16 won't stand as a valid document to claim your point.
 
MSA
2018-11-07
Skill
233914
SC
190(SA)
Point
65
EOI
2019-01-07
Inv.
2019-01-21
App.
2019-01-23
PCC
2019-01-29
HC
2019-02-01
Consider before posting:
  • Do not post the same thing in multiple places.
  • No personal contact and/or non-English phrase is allowed.
  • Always post in a relevant thread or open a new one.
  • Better to use the reactions in a post to congratulate/thank.
Top